How To Choose The Best Potatoes For Baking?

Everyone loves baked potatoes; they’re a comfort food classic. Choosing the proper potato variety is essential for making the ideal baked potato, whether you want it as a side dish or the main attraction. When it comes to baking, different potatoes have different qualities; picking the right one can change the flavor and texture immensely. This post will go over some important things to think about while choosing baking potatoes.

Starchy Vs. Waxy Potatoes

One of the most critical factors in choosing the best potatoes for baking is understanding the difference between starchy and waxy potatoes. Starchy potatoes, like Russet or Idaho potatoes, are ideal for baking because they have a high starch content. This starch transforms into a fluffy and light texture when baked, making it perfect for achieving that sought-after soft interior and crispy skin. On the other hand, waxy potatoes, such as red or Yukon Gold potatoes, are better suited for boiling, roasting, or making potato salads, as their lower starch content results in a denser texture.

Russet Potatoes: The Classic Choice

Classic and widely used, russet potatoes are the best option for baking. They are known for their high starch content, which creates a light and fluffy interior when baked. The thick and rough skin of Russets also crisps up nicely during baking, adding a delightful contrast in texture. If you’re a novice and don’t know how to cook a baked potato, start with Russets for a foolproof experience.

Size Matters

The size of the potato matters when it comes to baking. Smaller potatoes, like fingerlings or baby potatoes, are not well-suited for baking, as they lack the starch content needed to achieve that fluffy interior. Instead, opt for medium to large-sized potatoes for the best results. Larger potatoes allow for a more even cooking process and satisfying portion size.

Freshness Counts

When choosing potatoes for baking, it’s essential to select fresh ones. Fresh potatoes will have a firm and smooth texture without any wrinkles, soft spots, or sprouts. Avoid potatoes that are green-tinged, as this indicates the presence of a natural toxin called solanine, which can cause bitterness and gastrointestinal discomfort when consumed in large quantities.

Variety Matters

While Russet potatoes are the most commonly used for baking, there are other potato varieties to consider as well. For a slightly creamier texture with thin skin, you can opt for Yukon Gold potatoes. Red potatoes, while less starchy, can also be baked if you prefer a creamier and slightly waxy texture. Experimenting with different potato varieties can lead to unique and delicious results.

Consider Your Preferred Flavor

Potatoes vary in flavor, and your choice should align with your preferred taste profile. Because of their subtle, neutral flavor, russet potatoes can take on a wide variety of garnishes and seasonings. Yukon Gold potatoes offer a buttery and slightly sweet taste, enhancing the overall flavor of your baked potato. Red potatoes provide a subtle earthy flavor that pairs well with herbs and garlic. Think about the flavor you desire and select your potatoes accordingly.

Cooking Method Matters

Lastly, the cooking method you plan to use also influences your potato selection. If you’re planning to bake your potatoes in the oven at a high temperature, like for twice-baked potatoes, Russet potatoes are your best bet due to their ability to develop a crispy skin and tender interior. However, if you plan to use a lower temperature or bake them in foil, you can opt for waxy potatoes like Yukon Gold or red potatoes for a creamier result.


If you want your baked potatoes to be tasty and filling, you need to start by picking the right potatoes. Improving your baked potato skills requires knowledge of the distinctions between starchy and waxy potatoes, consideration of aspects like size and freshness, and experimentation with different varieties of potatoes. If you want perfectly cooked potatoes every time, follow these seven steps the next time you want this comfort food.